The Whispering Hillock quest in The Witcher 3 faces Geralt via a grim choice — this overview will certainly carry out all the tips you need to check out it through.

You are watching: Witcher 3 whispering hillock before meeting crones

Nobody says that The Witcher 3 is a cheery, happy game, and that"s for excellent factor. Quests prefer the Whispering Hillock display that the civilization included within is actually pretty grim. This mission work Geralt with finding out a spirit trapped inside a tree. You"ll have to decide what to carry out next, and also whatever before you execute, something devastating happens.

RELATED: The Witcher 3: How To Get To Kaer Morhen (And 9 Other Things About The Location)

Whispering Hillock"s consequences, unfortunately, create one of those lose-lose instances. You"ll have to decide who is even more essential to aid — a team of orphans or a local village.

This quest has a significant affect on the major story of the game, so you"ll want to make certain you"re making an increated alternative. Here"s everything you need to understand to finish the Whispering Hillock.

How to Start the Quest

the crones in the witcher 3
You"ll have the ability to find and activate this pursuit while proceeding via Velen"s primary storyline, complying with the story of the Baron and the Crones in the surrounding bog. You deserve to accidentally stumble upon the hillock beforehand, in which instance the game will certainly register this search as a side search, however frequently you"ll begin it as component of the main questline.

After helping Keira Metz in "Wandering in the Dark," she"ll provide Geralt a book that leads to the quest "Ladies of the Wood." As component of that quest, you"ll satisfy some orphans and a woguy named "Gran." After completing the missions of the search, Geralt will learn that tright here is an evil spirit inhabiting a nearby tree. This is where "The Whispering Hillock" begins.

whispering hillock werewolf
Head toward the supposedly-haunted tree, and also tright here will be some wolves and a werewolf to compete via, while a mysterious voice tells you to bugger off, basically. This combat percentage shouldn"t be also tough if you"re the recommfinished level, however werewolves have the right to periodically be a bit tricky if you aren"t prepared.

Use some Cursed Oil on your blade, and also employ a little bit of Axii or Yrden liberally, and also the werewolf shouldn"t be too a lot trouble. You have the right to likewise try to overlook it, as you"ll only need to fight it if you obtain as well cshed once trying to enter the cave.

the whispering hillock tree spirit
Once you traverse with the cave, you"ll come upon the stvariety soul trapped in the tree. If you found this search as component of the typical path, it"ll tell you about the Crones and the orphans. If you stumbled upon it, it"ll just point out why it was killing the locals without saying much more.

RELATED: The Witcher 3: Wbelow The Cat & Wolf Play (How To Activate It & Other Important Things You Need To Do)

Now, you"ll be presented with some options. What you decide to execute following will certainly have actually a huge influence on the following questline and also story, so you"ll have to select closely.

whispering hillock choices
Tbelow are basically three options for what to execute next. You deserve to agree to help the soul escape its entrapment, you have the right to opt for killing it, or you can deceive it.

Each of these decisions comes with some positive and also negative after-effects, and also in order to decide which, you might need to perform some soul-looking about your own worths.

Do you make an active option to save some innocent youngsters while unintentionally placing many various other world to fatality, or do you sacrifice the children to conserve the many? It"s an almost-precise replication of the classical philosophical trolley difficulty.

The first alternative you can make is to execute precisely what the heart asks of you — totally free it. You"ll have to gather 3 things. First, you"ll require a babsence equine, which you can uncover nearby by adhering to the objective marker. You can usage Axii on among them to tame it, but be mindful, as acquiring as well cshed as well easily will streatment the steeds off.

Next off, grab a raven"s feather west of Downwarren in a Harpy nest. You could currently have this if you assisted Johnny in the earlier quest. Lastly, discover a woman"s stays close to a water hag"s area in Crookago Bog. Then, go back to the heart.

If you select to release the spirit, it"ll hold up its end of the agreed barget and also whisk the orphans away from the Crones, eventually conserving them from ending up being a meal. You deserve to discover them later under the care of Marabella in Novigrad.

The Crones will retaliate against Gran (who it transforms out is actually the Baron"s wife, Anna) over the outrage from their loss. They"ll rotate her into a water hag, and also she"ll ultimately die. The Baron will certainly then kill himself out of grief over his loss of Anna. Furthermore, the soul will certainly ransack Downwarren, killing almost everyone in the village.

The second option you deserve to make is to kill the soul. This have the right to be done upfront before collecting the crucial points to complimentary it, or after you"ve gathered them. Either means, it"ll summon Endrega Workers as defense. Once they"ve been faced, you can strike the heart directly.

It"s not too challenging of a fight, however you may have actually some problems. Make great usage of Igni and Quen for this one.

If you decide to kill the soul, you will certainly conserve Downwarren from being massacred and also the Baron from shedding his wife. However before, nobody will be tbelow to save the orphans, and also the Crones will certainly take them (and also many likely eat them).

Anna will certainly finally lose what"s left of her fragile mind and also go insane over the loss of the kids. The Baron will whisk her amethod, out of Velen, to look for psychological health help. Downwarren will certainly likewise be safe and also cost-free to proceed worshipping the Crones.

Tright here is a third alternative, though. Geralt deserve to opt to trick the spirit, preventing having actually to kill it via combat. Once you"ve gathered the ingredients essential for releasing the spirit, you can choose not to stab the heart and also finish the routine.

The heart will certainly die and the pursuit will complete, and you won"t have actually had to unsheathe your sword.

If you aren"t pleased with the trolley problem presented from the initially 2 selections — conserve some negative orphans however sacrifice an entire village, the neighborhood ruler, and his wife, or conserve the village the couple while placing some innocent children to fatality — you can be happy to learn there"s a 3rd option.

However before, the consequences of tricking the soul aren"t much much better. The very same points will take place as if you killed the soul through combat, as it won"t be alive to conserve the orphans. The Crones will certainly still eat them, Anna will certainly still go insane, and also Downwarren will certainly still stand also.

Regardmuch less of which choice you make, tright here are some other necessary things to note about this quest. Consulting the ealdormale in Downwarren is an important action, and also if skipped, have the right to cause some weird results to occur. If you don"t talk to him before the soul dies (either through combat or tricking it), the normal "the heart is dead" consequences take area.

However, if you opt to cost-free the spirit and haven"t spoken to the ealdorman yet, weird stuff happens. Downwarren will still be ruined, yet Anna will certainly not be turned into a water hag. Ensuing dialogue will certainly indicate that the orphans were saved, yet they won"t be in Novigrad at Marabella"s favor they would certainly be if you did the quest the argued method, implying that they possibly weren"t saved.

Furthermore, regardmuch less of your choices, the Baron will no longer ascendancy at Crow"s Perch, either because he eliminated himself or bereason he fled the area via Anna to uncover her help. His Sergeant, Ardal, will take over. He"ll dominion with a harsh iron fist over the area, unfortunately. Aacquire, nobody shelp this was a cheery game.

NEXT: The Witcher 3: Eincredibly Mini Ending You Can Get Throughout The Game (& How To Get Them)

See more: Why Isn'T It Possible To Follow Topics On Pinterest Topics On A Pc Or Mac

Destiny 2: How To Get Ager"s Scepter And All Atlas Skews Discover the place of eexceptionally Atlas Skew to attain this damaging Stasis Trace Rifle.

Michael is an editor at and also a journalist via several years of suffer writing about video games, television, and social problems. He loves indie platformers, Pokémon, and Hack "n Slashers.Currently playing: Genshin Impact, No Man"s Sky, and also Stardew Valley.