The Whispering Hillock pursuit in The Witcher 3 faces Geralt v a grim choice — this overview will provide all the advice you have to see it through.

You are watching: Witcher 3 whispering hillock before meeting crones

Nobody states that The Witcher 3 is a cheery, happy game, and that"s for good reason. Quests favor the Whispering Hillock present that the people contained within is in reality pretty grim. This mission tasks Geralt with finding out a heart trapped within a tree. You"ll have to decide what to do next, and whatever girlfriend do, something destructive happens.

RELATED: The Witcher 3: how To gain To Kaer Morhen (And 9 various other Things about The Location)

Whispering Hillock"s consequences, unfortunately, form among those lose-lose situations. You"ll have to decide that is more important to assist — a group of orphans or a local village.

This quest has a far-reaching impact top top the key story the the game, so you"ll desire to make sure you"re do an informed choice. Here"s every little thing you need to understand to complete the Whispering Hillock.

just how to start the Quest

the crones in the witcher 3
You"ll be able to find and also activate this quest while advancing through Velen"s main storyline, complying with the story the the Baron and also the Crones in the surrounding bog. You have the right to accidentally stumble upon the hillock early, in which case the game will it is registered this search as a next quest, however typically you"ll begin it as part of the key questline.

After help Keira Metz in "Wandering in the Dark," she"ll give Geralt a publication that leads to the quest "Ladies of the Wood." As part of the quest, you"ll satisfy some orphans and a woman called "Gran." After completing the missions of the quest, Geralt will discover that over there is an evil soul inhabiting a nearby tree. This is whereby "The Whispering Hillock" begins.

whispering hillock werewolf
Head toward the supposedly-haunted tree, and there will be some wolves and a werewolf to complete with, while a secret voice tells you come bugger off, basically. This combat portion shouldn"t it is in too tough if you"re the encourage level, but werewolves deserve to sometimes be a little tricky if you aren"t prepared.

use some Cursed Oil on her blade, and employ a little bit of Axii or Yrden liberally, and also the werewolf shouldn"t be too lot trouble. You deserve to also shot to neglect it, as you"ll only have to fight that if you acquire too close once trying to get in the cave.

the whispering hillock tree spirit
as soon as you traverse v the cave, you"ll come top top the strange heart trapped in the tree. If you uncovered this quest as part of the common route, it"ll tell you about the Crones and the orphans. If girlfriend stumbled top top it, it"ll only mention why it was killing the locals without saying lot more.

RELATED: The Witcher 3: wherein The Cat & wolf Play (How to Activate that & Other vital Things You should Do)

Now, you"ll it is in presented v some options. What you decide to do following will have actually a huge influence top top the adhering to questline and story, therefore you"ll have actually to pick carefully.

whispering hillock choices
There are basically three selections for what to perform next. You can agree to help the heart escape its entrapment, you have the right to opt because that killing it, or you can deceive it.

each of this decisions comes with some hopeful and an adverse consequences, and in bespeak to decision which, you can have to carry out some soul-searching concerning your own values.

carry out you make an active selection to save some innocent kids while unintentionally putting many other people to death, or carry out you sacrifice the kids to conserve the many? It"s an almost-exact replication of the standard philosophical trolley problem.

The very first choice you deserve to make is to do exactly what the soul asks of you — cost-free it. You"ll need to gather 3 things. First, you"ll need a black horse, which you deserve to find surrounding by complying with the objective marker. You can use Axii on among them come tame it, yet be careful, as obtaining too close too quickly will scare the equines off.

Next, grab a raven"s feather west that Downwarren in a Harpy nest. Friend might currently have this if you assisted Johnny in the previously quest. Lastly, find a woman"s remains near a water hag"s region in Crookback Bog. Then, return to the spirit.

If you select to release the spirit, it"ll organize up its finish of the i agree bargain and also whisk the orphans far from the Crones, ultimately saving castle from becoming a meal. Girlfriend can find them later under the care of Marabella in Novigrad.

The Crones will certainly retaliate versus Gran (who it turns out is in reality the Baron"s wife, Anna) over the upset from your loss. They"ll turn her into a water hag, and also she"ll ultimately die. The Baron will certainly then kill himself out of grief end his lose of Anna. Additionally, the soul will ransack Downwarren, killing almost everyone in the village.

The second choice you have the right to make is to death the spirit. This deserve to be excellent upfront prior to collecting the important things to totally free it, or after ~ you"ve accumulated them. One of two people way, it"ll summon Endrega employees as protection. Once they"ve to be dealt with, friend can strike the love directly.

It"s not too challenging of a fight, however you may have actually some issues. Make great use the Igni and Quen for this one.

If you decide to death the spirit, friend will conserve Downwarren from being massacred and also the Baron from shedding his wife. However, nobody will be over there to conserve the orphans, and also the Crones will take castle (and most likely eat them).

Anna will certainly finally lose what"s left of her breakable mind and walk insane end the lose of the children. The Baron will certainly whisk her away, the end of Velen, to seek mental health and wellness help. Downwarren will additionally be safe and free to continue worshipping the Crones.

there is a 3rd option, though. Geralt can opt to trick the spirit, staying clear of having to death it through combat. When you"ve gathered the ingredients crucial for freeing the spirit, girlfriend can choose not to stab the heart and complete the ritual.

The heart will die and the search will finish, and also you won"t have had to unsheathe her sword.

If girlfriend aren"t pleased v the trolley trouble presented from the very first two options — conserve some negative orphans however sacrifice whole village, the local ruler, and also his wife, or save the village the couple while putting some innocent kids to death — you might be happy to find out there"s a third option.

However, the aftermath of tricking the soul aren"t lot better. The very same things will take place as if you killed the soul through combat, together it won"t be lively to save the orphans. The Crones will certainly still eat them, Anna will certainly still walk insane, and Downwarren will still stand.

nevertheless of which an option you make, there space some other necessary things come note about this quest. Consulting the ealdorman in Downwarren is critical step, and also if skipped, can cause some weird consequences to occur. If friend don"t talk to him prior to the soul dies (either through combat or tricking it), the typical "the heart is dead" aftermath take place.

However, if friend opt to free the spirit and haven"t talked to the ealdorman yet, weird ingredient happens. Downwarren will still it is in destroyed, but Anna will certainly not be turned right into a water hag. Ensuing dialogue will suggest that the orphans were saved, but they won"t be in Novigrad at Marabella"s choose they would be if you did the search the said way, implying that they maybe weren"t saved.

Additionally, nevertheless of your choices, the Baron will certainly no longer dominion at Crow"s Perch, either because he eliminated himself or due to the fact that he fled the an ar with Anna to discover her help. His Sergeant, Ardal, will certainly take over. He"ll ascendancy with a harsh iron fist over the region, unfortunately. Again, nobody said this was a cheery game.

NEXT: The Witcher 3: Every Mini finishing You Can obtain Throughout The video game (& how To acquire Them)

See more: Why Isn'T It Possible To Follow Topics On Pinterest Topics On A Pc Or Mac

Destiny 2: exactly how To obtain Ager"s Scepter and also All Atlas Skews uncover the place of every Atlas Skew to acquire this damaging Stasis map Rifle.

Michael is one editor in ~ and also a journalist with number of years of endure writing about video games, television, and social issues. The loves indie platformers, Pokémon, and also Hack "n Slashers.Currently playing: Genshin Impact, No Man"s Sky, and also Stardew Valley.