Pinterest email Send Text message print Comment


Who killed Sister Cathy? The Keepers, from director Ryan White, dives right into the life and also untimely death of a Baltimore nun, whose unsolved killing still lingers virtually five years after the fact. Together you dive right into Netflix’s chilling true-crime series, follow follow me as us recap each of the 7 episodes here, one revelation in ~ a time. Be mindful before analysis (and virwandachamber.orging): some subject matter may be disturbing.

You are watching: The keepers season 1 episode 7

In 1969, Cathy Cesnik, 26-year-old nun and beloved high college teacher, was murdered in Baltimore — and the crime was never solved. This very first episode lays the end the facts of the case, and the tireless crusaders — plucky former students the Sister Cathy’s, now well right into their 60s — who have been fighting to piece together the truth of this murky nightmare. A warning:The content of this series can be an overwhelming at times, so (and watch) in ~ your very own discretion.

There’s journalist Tom Nugent, that wrote a comprehensive story ~ above the murder years ago and has actually been haunted by it ever since. Then there are Cesnik’s former students Gemma Hoskins, a “bulldog” unafraid to ask anyone any question, and also Abbie Shaub, a soft-spoken study whiz, that run a Facebook page where people likrwandachamber.orgise obsessed with the case can post any information they uncover out — or psychic — around Sister Cathy’s disappearance and also death. “Our issue is the she dropped into other evil and got recorded up through it,” lock say. “We’re called the story is not the nun’s killing. The story is the cover-up that the nun’s story.” They’re ~ above something.

The details that the case, told with a chorus of voices, space these: sister Cathy to be beloved in ~ Archbishop Keough High School, the Catholic all-girls college where she teach English. (Now, the school is dubbed Seton Keough High School.) Students linked with her in component because she wasn’t lot older than they were, but likrwandachamber.orgise because she was bright and passionate, and also made texts choose Romeo and Juliet and The Scarlet Letter come alive for she students.

On Friday, November 7, 1969, Cathy left work around 3:00 p.m. And also returned come the apartment she common with another nun, sister Russell. She’d called multiple world she was going come buy one engagement gift for she sister that night, and also seemed excited around it. Sister Cathy supposedly left she apartment parking lot approximately 7:00 p.m., cashed her paycheck at the local bank, saw the bakery for dinner roles, then checked out the neighborhood shopping center, Edmondson Village, come buy the engagement gift. (The holder depicts sister Cathy’s journey v a map that the area and a clock measuring out the hours of the evening.) Eyrwandachamber.orgitnesses observed her grocery shopping, and one trust she observed her sit in the automobile in the parking lot together if she was waiting for something. Account vary regarding whether sister Cathy ever before made it earlier to her apartment facility after the shopping trip.

Another previous student, mar Kreig, recalls gift in the area wherein Sisters Cathy and also Russell live that night come peek into the apartment of Mr. Noone, a teacher she and her friend had actually a like on. They heard yelling from the direction of Sister Cathy’s apartment. “It to be a man’s voice. Loud, booming. Garbled v emotion, anger. Us really thought it was some sort of violence the was walk on increase there,” she recalls.

At 11:30 p.m., sister Russell started to gain nervous the Sister Cathy hadn’t acquired home yet, so she called a fellow teacher and Sister Cathy’s friend, a priest called Gerry Koob. He and also Brother Peter had actually seen Easy driver that night in Baltimore, however rushed come Sister Russell’s and spent 45 minute listening to her tell the story. By that point, Gerry says, it to be three hrs after she had actually expected them, for this reason they determined to contact the police and also report her together a lacking person. Gerry said Mass, saving some bread for Cathy if she returned home. In the early, beforehand hours of the morning, the guys left the apartment and noticed that Cathy’s automobile was mysteriously parked ~ above the street, keys in the ignition, v its rear sticking out right into the street surrounding to the apartment. The car was muddy, and also there was a twig inside near the steering wheel. It was clear come Gerry that the vehicle had been in a swampy area — and that whoever put it earlier wanted the to it is in found.

The plot thickens: 3 days later, an additional young woman went absent and was later uncovered dead. Joyce Malecki, 20, had also gone shopping and also never returned, and also her auto was found unlocked through the keys in the ignition. She’d switched car with one of her brothers earlier that day, leaving her auto with him and also taking their parents’ car. Joyce’s body was uncovered facedown in a stream, through her throat cut and also hands bound behind her back. Gemma and also Abbie have actually been working through Joyce’s brothers to continue making connections between the two situations in the hopes that they have the right to solve both at the same time.

Here, we fulfill John Barnold, the former chief the homicide that the Baltimore City Police Department. He to be continually quoted at the moment as speak they didn’t think sister Cathy’s loss was a kidnapping. Now, gift intervirwandachamber.orged for The Keepers, he describes that he was supervising so many robberies, homicides, sex offenses, assaults — he couldn’t dedicate his time to one particular case.

It wasn’t till mid-January 1970 the Sister Cathy’s body was finally discovered by hunters: She was lying on her ago near a rubbish dump with her skull caved in. The retired policeman on the case, James Scannell, take away Gemma, a useful man they met through the Facebook team named Alan Horn, and the documentary come the spot whereby he discovered the body. Scannell is soft spoken, and also it’s hard to call if he’s senile or simply old. The remembers the condition of sister Cathy’s human body in great detail and says, “I think she was probably dumped there. She hadn’t deteriorated — no maggots or anything choose that.” Gemma is suspicious of him and also tries to watch if he can aid them get the full report indigenous the BCPD, yet he pen it off, saying no one at the office would recognize him anymore.

In more conversations with journalists and also longtime Baltimore residents, civilization posit the the human who eliminated Cathy she very, very well — and also that the police and also FBI most likely an ext than they let on about both Cathy and Joyce Malecki’s deaths, yet Baltimore’s widespread corruption and strict hierarchies are preventing information from gaining out.

In the episode’s final moments, we find out that there to be one witness, a mrs Doe, who was a student at Keough and also claimed to have seen the body. Go Jane Doe organize the tricks to unlocking this mystery?

Who eliminated Cathy and also Joyce and why — and also was it the exact same person?Why would the killer (presumably) return the cars?Why did Joyce switch cars through her brother?Who is mrs Doe?Why room the police and FBI extending this up, if castle are?Why were the 2 women murdered in such various ways?Is Scannell hiding something?

Well, we don’t need to wait lengthy to discover out the identification of mrs Doe: episode 2 comes right out through it. Her surname is Jean Hargadon Wehner, and she was raised in a quintessential Baltimore Catholic family: full of children, very devout, and very involved in the city’s Catholic community. Her father to be a policeman, and her mommy took ~ above the function of a good Catholic wife, popping out a boy every 11 month or so.

A great chunk of time is spent describing just how wonderful Keough was an alleged to be, and how excited students to be to discover they’d happen the admissions test and were embraced to the school. The picture of this perfect school is quickly shattered, though, together Jean starts to recount her harrowing story.

As a freshman, Jean states she went to confession and confided in the priest, father Magnus, that her uncle had actually sexually abused her as soon as she was younger. But instead of make the efforts to help Jean v this, Magnus asked she name and also to look at at her (for non-Catholics, this clear is never a component of confession), and told her, “I don’t really know if God have the right to forgive this.” A pair weeks later — and also this is very disturbing to hear and also read, so continue with caution — Magnus and also another priest, father Maskell, that held good sway in the school, dubbed her into an office and began to sexually abuse her also further, calling your semen “the holy Spirit” and “the Eucharist.” “He was reminding me that the points I had done weren’t excellent to me, that I had made those points happen,” she says.

During these “therapy sessions,” as the priests encouraged a naïve and traumatized Jean lock were, castle would call her a whore and pray over she in Latin as they raped her. “They were an effective because they represented God,” she remembers. “I want to acquire out of that room, and also yet i felt that i had to it is in in the room in bespeak to it is in a an excellent person.” ~ a while, the was simply Maskell abusing she — though sometimes he’d bring people in to abuse Jean together he watched and also guarded the door. Once, he brought a gun, eliminated the bullets, and also put it come Jean’s temple, telling her the if her father discovered out she’d been “whoring around,” he’d carry out the same to her — there is no removing the bullets.

Maskell had a strange childhood the his own: His mommy started grooming him to it is in a priest at a young age, make him say Mass top top the former yard and use Necco wafers together make-believe Communion hosts. A former altar boy, Brian Schwaab, recalls that as soon as Maskell was working as a monk in the local church, he carried a gun come the sacristy, and Brian asked why a priest necessary to lug a handgun. “I’ll never ever forget the look he gave me… ns didn’t acquire a look choose that till years later on intervirwandachamber.orging violent offenders,” that says.

As the turned out, Jean wasn’t the only Keough student enduring terrible, violent abuse at the hands of father Maskell: he preyed on various other students who had actually histories the abuse, too, so lot that once he’d call a surname over the P.A. For a student to concerned his office, a hush would fall over the class as the various other girls looked on in devastation and pity, if the teachers just said lock Maskell was weird but the student had actually to go. “Teachers would certainly look down,” one former student recalls. “They something was going on.”

Father Maskell to be the college counselor and had a Master’s degree in institution psychology — therefore the horrific irony of the instance is the the really person college student should have actually been maybe to go to for assist was the one tormenting them. One student, Lillian Hughes, acquired a project as his assistant, and he’d have her kind up her classmates’ documents — most of which to be sexual. She now believes that as soon as he offered her a cup the Coke every day, that was likrwandachamber.orgise drugging her. She memories of the time room foggy. She go recall that Maskell put the Alfred Hitchcock movie Marnie into the school’s religion curriculum, which centers top top a woman through repressed memory of abuse.

Another keep in mind on Maskell: Not only was that the chaplain for the Maryland State Police, but his brother, Tommy Maskell, was a Baltimore City policeman, and Maskell self was close friends with several cops. Jean also recalls Maskell pass a cop into the room to abuse her. Also though he said he didn’t desire to, Maskell encouraged him.

Finally, one college student confided in sister Cathy, and also Cathy at some point asked Jean about the abuse, too. Jean confided in she at the finish of the college year, and also Cathy told she she would take treatment of it. However at the start of the next school year, sisters Cathy and Sister Russell obtained permission to leave Keough and live outside of the convent in one apartment and also to teach in a public school, partly so that they might be “out in the world” and help understand much more what your students’ stays were like.

Gerry Koob, the former priest sisters Russell called the night the Cathy’s disappearance, additionally confides the at this time, he and Cathy had actually grown close and also realized they to be soulmates, however when the proposed the he leave the priesthood and also she skip her final vows and they obtain married instead, she turned that down. The day she was killed, Cathy had actually told Gerry there to be something major she want to talk to the about. He assumed it was to re-open the conversation about marriage, yet now the realizes, much more likely, she to be going to tell him about the abuse at Keough.

Fast forward to November 1969, two days before Cathy go missing: one of the abused student — together of best now, anonymous — and her boyfriend saw the sisters’ apartment to visit, but Fathers Maskell and Magnus burst into the apartment there is no knocking. The student recalls that “Maskell looked furious” yet “Magnus looked dumb.” Cathy sent the student and her friend away, but the next day, Maskell allegedly told the couple he’d kill both of them, and their totality families, if castle talked.

Back in ~ Keough, Jean describes that Maskell referred to as her right into his office, and he frantically told she Cathy to be missing, however then claimed that that wherein she was, and also could take her there. He drove her to the woods, where she saw among Cathy’s shoes on the ground… and then her body. “There to be maggots on her face,” Jean recalls, speak she maintained wiping Cathy’s face and also crying, “Please help me! Please aid me!” At that point, she says Father Maskell bent under to her and said, “You check out what happens as soon as you say bad things about people?”

• Why wasn’t Joyce Malecki mentioned in this episode? Is her murder not linked with Cathy’s after ~ all? OR… was she also an abused student?• who was the anonymous student Maskell threatened?• who did sisters Cathy tell about Father Maskell’s abuse? go she phone call someone rather first, or go right to Maskell himself?• who else about the murder and helped cover that up?• Did dad Maskell actually death her, or did he gain someone else to execute it?• Why did Jean to speak Cathy’s confront was extended in maggots, as soon as Scannell specifically told Gemma the her face didn’t have any maggots on it?• yet perhaps the fieriest of these burning questions: how is this story going come stretch across five much more episodes? in ~ this point, it appears pretty cut-and-dry: There were a pair horrifyingly sadistic clergymans who arranged because that Sister Cathy’s death when she threatened to revolve them in, and the police and the remainder of the Catholic town safeguarded them. Ns guess this is a really early take (and just a huge hypothesis) however I’ve seen Spotlight. Isn’t this kind of the same story?

The second episode that The Keepers ended with such a dramatic bomb blast the it’s only normal for a stare dust settling in this third hour. Netflix streaming kind of loss the suggest of cliffhangers, because there’s no hold-up of gratification till the next episode. Yet still: Jean Hargadon Wehner’s macabre description in the final minute of illustration 2, finish with black-and-white reenactment, of an afternoon in November 1969, is heart-in-your-throat TV. Jean claimed she was led right into the woods by dad Joseph Maskell and also taunted with the dead body of sister Cathy Cesnik. “You what happens when you say negative things about people,” he told her.

When the Huffington short article published a longform story around this same instance two year ago, writer Laura Bassett opened the item with that shocking incident. The Keepers director Ryan White (who previously made docs on Prop 8 and Serena Williams) is an ext of a Shyamalan-showman. Episode 3 deals mainly with Jean’s poignant backstory (more on that below), however White reaches for the cliffhanger magic again, finishing this 64-minute episode a little bit clumsily with the revelation the a important individual called, if you have the right to actually think it, Deep Throat.

This Deep throat is a super-secret Baltimore detective with a story to tell about secret document boxes that were hidden in a cemetery dig by dad Maskell. He to be so nicknamed by the amateur sleuths (and noticeable Watergate nostalgists) Gemma Hoskins and Abbie Schaub. However as adorable together those two women are, White could have been more careful that the line in between portraying them and also becoming them. The shrouded-in-mystery revelation the Deep throat — cue mood music and another onscreen graphic of a black color silhouette — feels much more manufactured than powerful.

But that’s just one ding versus what is overall a patient and also expertly built episode. Right here are the five points of interest to dig right into as you’re watching:

Despite the incalculable horror that Wehner explains living through as a teenager, the illustration is touching for exactly how it chronicles the humongous assistance of she family. That contains her husband Mike (“the lifesaver that got thrown in because that me,” she says), her two kids Sarah and Greg, add to a cadre of brothers and sisters, who like Hoskins and also Schaub likrwandachamber.orgise moonlight as detectives to aid discover the truth.

It was a opportunity meeting v a real estate agent and also former high school classmate in 1992 that caused Wehner to purge long-dormant storage of the abuse she suffered. A future episode will take a deep dive into amnesia and also the mental basis for just how traumatic events are repressed, for this reason we’ll organize of on that conversation for now. However Wehner’s description of unlocking her past is intense and vivid: “It was like ripping masks off her face and also looking in a mirror as you’re doing it.” (Also to it is in explored later in the collection will it is in the Church’s attempts to render Wehner together an unreliable witness.)

Wehner and her siblings recall a family meeting in the early 1990s, where her subconscious burst choose a balloon. She screamed, “I loved her and I killed her,” concerning Sister Cathy. The illustration doesn’t spell out this fact, therefore it’s worth clarifying: Wehner’s overwhelming guilt stems indigenous her id that she triggered a collection of occasions that brought about Sister Cathy’s death. In she mind, that’s akin to having actually slain the mrs herself. But Wehner is no saying that she literally killed Cathy with her very own hand.

In a moment that echoes the finishing of Spotlight, Wehner’s lawyer Beverly Wallace defines the deluge of letter that she got from various other students in ~ Archbishop Keough High School. The famed Boston Globe Church abuse nrwandachamber.orgspaper write-ups (the basis for the Oscar-winning move) space name-checked in this episode. As in Boston, various other victims were influenced to share their stories as soon as the door was creaked open. In Baltimore, a classified advertisement was put in a nrwandachamber.orgspaper, and Wehner’s family mailed a thousand letter to former alumnae that Archbishop Keough. In a fascinating detail, Wehner’s adolescent nephrwandachamber.orgs are described as praying over the letters before they got in the mailbox.

Teresa Lancaster is just one of those that responded, and her testimony is equal to Wehner’s in its dreadful weight. “I have the right to tell you stuff you won’t think that did,” she says. In a docuseries that absolutely doesn’t lack for horrific descriptions of rape and also abuse, the many ghoulish for this reason far might be Lancaster’s retelling that her experience on Halloween night in 1970. She alleges Maskell take it her into a wooded area, wherein she was raped by police officers. Absorb the timeline: October 31, 1970. That’s practically exactly one year after ~ — after — sisters Cathy walk missing.

It’s a detail that comes out an extremely quickly in the show, but we have to pause to acknowledge a nun named Sister Marylita Friia. She to be the “no-nonsense” sister that was appointed principal of Archbishop Keough in 1975, and upon hearing complaints from parental of students in ~ the school, Maylita took action. “She told that he had 15 minute to load his things and also get out,” Gemma Hoskins says.

Granted, it’s true that she could likrwandachamber.orgise have alerted law enforcement authorities around Maskell, however we don’t understand what she was or wasn’t aware of. Much more than 40 years later, it’s at the very least comforting to know that who sniffed out Maskell for the venomous slob she was.

The illustration jumps ahead in the timeline to define an the Father Maskell offered to the Baltimore Sun nrwandachamber.orgspaper in respectable 1994. “Hysterical nonsense” is exactly how the priest’s defensive, deny-everything stance to be described. This to be after a round the allegations had actually been leveled versus him and also the Church to be taking activity — by sending him to rehab for every the stress he to be experiencing since of the accusations.

The post by Robert A. Erlandson and Joe Nawrozki (real the complete text here) offers a backstory on Maskell but very quotes v the man. Among the many tantalizing contributions in the short article comes from a woman named Attilia Marasa, who operated in the high school’s office.

“I think dad Maskell’s above reproach, an upstanding priest. All this crap that’s coming out about priests is just to gain money native the Catholic Church,” she’s quoted as having said. “If it had happened to me the would have been report at once, you have the right to bet her bippy top top that. Ns would have gone appropriate away come the archdiocese, don’t wait 25 years. The girl should have told your parents right away and also gotten a lawyer and also reported come the archdiocese.”

The Keepers is like a swift kick to the hornet’s colony that is Baltimore, implicating cops and lawyers and politicians as well as the priests. Dr. Richter is the gynecologist Teresa Lancaster describes seeing on dad Maskell’s insistence. Richter died 11 years ago, and also this obituary merely explains him together a Civil battle buff and an excellent doctor.

Episode 3 steers into Wehner’s life story and also for understandable factors abandons the various other murder, that of 20-year-old Malecki. Her name never comes up throughout this hour — but hopefully the isn’t true because that the rest of the series.

Dr. L.M. Lothstein offers haunting testimony ~ above camera about his time working at Connecticut’s academy of Living. Lothstein insurance claims that the Catholic Church to be sending priests to the Institute who were guilty the abusing children, under the phony symptom that depression. “It happened over and over again,” Lothstein says. The sounds prefer there could be a seven-hour Netflix display just about that.

In its first three hours, The Keepers has pulsed through a low-growl menace akin to mental horror movies. The nightmarish abuse suffered — allegedly, uh what — by woman students at Archbishop Keough High college is appalling even apart indigenous the killing of Cathy Cesnik and Joyce Malecki. Through the end of episode 4 (of course, a cliffhanger), the story feels conveniently as disturbing together the spookiest thought in director David Lynch’s head.

As critic Jeff Jensen has currently pointed out in his, Lynch’s obsessions echo in The Keepers’ darkest corners: “sexual abuse, psychic manipulation, and a society that preys on women.” however the late arrival of a figure in The Keepers’ tangled web takes the prize for creepiest link to Lynch, in this instance the director’s soon-resurrected Twin Peaks. Brother Bob, a faceless monster-person indigenous victim Jean Wehner’s memory who boasted around murdering sister Cathy, can’t assist but churn up our own memories that this demon indigenous Lynch’s initial series:

Brother Bob’s identification will presumably be more explored in later on episodes. However what’s truly unnerving, despite a couple of moments that lightness within the gloom that this hour, is that Bob is simply one the a collection of suspicious personalities introduced. Below are the five significant points of understand from illustration 4.

In last episode’s recap, I connected to the obituary of Dr. Christian Richter, the gynecologist that we uncover out below was included as a defendant in woman Doe and Jane Roe’s at some point unsuccessful lawsuit. However now we also hear around Paul McHugh, pseudo-intellectual (in mine opinion) psychiatrist at Johns Hopkins Hospital, who megaphones his virulent anti-LGBT virwandachamber.orgs to help the Catholic Church in sex abuse cases. A self-described “orthodox Catholic,” the was critical in obtaining the 1994 lawsuit dismissed. For years, McHugh has asserted that homosexuality is the root case of boy sex abuse in his Church. Presumably, per the logic, McHugh would aid in exonerating a priest choose Father Maskell since he targeted females?

Unsurprisingly, McHugh would not agree to it is in intervirwandachamber.orged because that The Keepers. A lifetime of being a toady and also sycophant could have captured up v him. In McHugh’s dotage (he’s 86), the man perhaps has finally found a sense of shame.

Lee Richmond to be a professor at Johns Hopkins who ended up being friends through Father Maskell in 1982 ~ he took a food on community counseling. She mentions the she was as soon as planning ~ above visiting the in 1990 as soon as he defined he was busy burying a bunch that old office papers in his cemetery. Huh? Is that was her friends execute on the weekends?

The anonymous Baltimore detective known as Deep Throat, who voice has been changed so the he sounds prefer RoboCop v laryngitis, cases that there were nude photographs the girls amongst the files. “That’s a typical pedophile,” Deep throat says. “A pedophile cannot separate from his collection. Also if the can’t acquire to it, he to know it’s there.” over there was enough to arrest Maskell on the spot, that says, yet “the department chief ran interference v the Church.”

Deep Throat’s comment around the division chief leads into this episode’s more fascinating, tough-to-decipher Sharon A.H. May functioned for the State’s Attorney’s Office from 1983 come 2004, and also she explains going to holy Cross Cemetery ~ above the day the the papers were exhumed.

“To my recollection there was nothing found,” she says. In ~ first, May appears to be bobbing and obfuscating in her guarded, I-do-not-recall answers to manager Ryan White. (White introduces might from a surreptitious camera angle as she’s solving her hairdo in a winter — a cheap shot.) however have we become too accustomed to enablers that violence in Baltimore flying out of the hornet’s swarm that we as an audience job a feeling of guilt ~ above May’s statements?

Was she also involved in a conspiracy to protect Maskell indigenous the law? No way, she says. “I was not one to it is in intimidated,” might remarks, adding for great measure that she is no now and has never ever been a Catholic. However in 4 episodes the The Keepers, there’s no been a person’s confront that I’ve learned as carefully as May’s. One of two people she’s informing the fact or she’s not telling the truth — and also if it’s the latter, what stories she must have.

In the episode’s most moving segment, we learn that Teresa Lancaster (the “Jane Roe” from the 1994 lawsuit versus the Church) got her law level at period 49. And also it’s in ~ this suggest where the display evokes the Freddie Gray case, enabling Lancaster’s voice to map the reverberations of injustice and pain native decades back to today. It’s an ambitious leap for The Keepers come make, however one the feels correctly earned.

The two plaintiffs in the 1994 instance have purposefully never encountered each other. Wehner claims it was because she didn’t want a tardy of an additional victim’s testimony affecting her own. But is the show leading up to a get-together in between the 2 women?

In a step that’s essentially a replay the a minute from episode 1, we again see the white-haired Scannell mumble v an explanation of recognize Sister Cathy’s body. Currently we uncover out the he, like Paul McHugh, denies the concept of recovered memories. And also he claims that father Maskell’s actual craving to be to work-related in law enforcement. Please, enable him come babble on.

The kidnapping and also murder the Malecki has now not been touch upon for 3 episodes. Here’s hoping the The Keepers returns to her story soon. This whole thing would certainly be easier if Malecki weren’t in the picture as well, however the display shouldn’t ~ pretend she isn’t. What if father Maskell and also the boogeyman brother Bob have the right to be associated to Malecki? that sure changes the form of things.

As us all know by this point, The Keepers is a murder secret story unlike any type of other. The slim amount the time that has actually passed due to the fact that Sister Cathy Cesnik’s murder changes the story’s usual formula, due to the fact that most of the people affiliated are lengthy dead. It’s tough to supply justice to father Joseph Maskell, because that instance, due to the fact that he’s in the ground. And even prior to he died, together Lil Hughes tells us at the optimal of the episode, Maskell to be hospitalized and sick, and his eyes were empty. In his later on years at the dementia ward, she once tried to acquire up in his face and also confront him around what he’d done, but even she might tell there was no point by then.

So what’s left to perform if the large bad guy is beyond justice? Well, even if Maskell is guilty of instigating Cathy’s death, it’s unlikely the he did for this reason alone. In Maskell’s absence, the best option is to find out that else to be involved and also what your stories have the right to tell. Luckily, Abbie and also Gemma’s anonymous reminder line soon bears unexpected fruit. They get two various versions of a very similar-sounding story: “I think mine uncle killed Sister Cathy.”

The very first niece in question is Debbie Yohn. She uncle, Edgar Davidson, to be an erratic and also combustible guy. Come hear her aunt “Margaret” (not her genuine name) phone call it, Edgar came residence with a bloody shirt and a questionable alibi on the night the Nov. 7, 1969, the exact same night the Sister Cathy disappeared. Job later, as soon as Cathy’s disappearance very first made the nrwandachamber.orgs, Margaret recalls Edgar’s reaction: rocking back in his chair, smirking, talking around how she’ll probably be hidden in the eye by the moment they find her. Quickly thereafter, Edgar got tires because that their auto — supposedly because that the winter, however maybe also to change his car’s incriminating tires tracks.

There are even much more shady details. Cathy disappeared ~ buying an engagement existing for she sister, yet the existing was never ever found. Funnily enough, that Christmas, Edgar got Margaret a beautiful piece of jrwandachamber.orgelry: a necklace v a environment-friendly rhinestone. She can tell it was never ever intended because that her; ~ burying the in a edge of she jrwandachamber.orgelry crate for years, she’s passed the on to Debbie, that now simply wants come return it come the human it to be intended for.

Sharon Schmidt has actually a similar story. She patent remembers overhearing an argument in between her parents in which she dad said, “You wanna recognize why i drink? since we killed a woman and put her behind the shop.” Cathy’s body remained in fact discovered near the Schmidt household business, and as we heard in previously episodes, dumping her there would’ve required details knowledge of the area. Whether Sharon’s dad was connected in the death or just helped her uncle, Billy, dispose the the body, he too came home with a bloody shirt the night but no visible injuries (much choose Edgar) and afterward came to be a hefty drinker.

Like Maskell, Billy Schmidt is dead now, for this reason his can be fried culpability in Cathy’s murder can remain a mystery forever. However regardless the his precise involvement, it’s clear the the unanswered inquiries inflicted deep, deep wounds ~ above himself and his family. Billy, who currently had to resolve the troubles of gift a closeted homosexual guy in the repressive Catholic setting of ‘70s Baltimore, invested years after ~ Cathy’s fatality screaming around “the woman in the attic,” and also committed self-destruction not long after.

Sharon’s brother Brian was haunted through Cathy’s murder, too. 6 months prior to he passed away of a heart attack, Brian called researcher Alan Horn the he had a distinctive storage of one Uncle Bobby maintaining him populated as a tiny child if Billy and also his mysterious girlfriend “Skippy” disposed of a rolled-up rug in the woods. As Brian told Horn, “this is a child’s memory in one old man’s body” — so he thought nothing of it at the time, only to later on realize it was probably Sister Cathy’s body.

Tragically, Brian never ever breathed a native of this to his sister, that unbeknownst come him was also suffering native unresolved questions around their family’s joining in Cathy’s murder. Sharon states that learning about this just after Brian’s fatality was “hard to take.” It’s the latest instance in this show of a person being shoved confront to confront with unspeakable trauma in ~ a young age, and instead of offering a assistance system, their community just required them come repress that damages until the poisoned or killed them. The show doesn’t draw a straight connection in between Brian’s heart attack and the built-up push of maintaining such anxiety inside himself for decades, however Jean has just together a disastrous formulation about her so late husband Mike.

In Jean’s words, Mike “swallowed a many anger” end the years. Standing by she side v her traumatic confrontations with the Church frequently meant keeping his mouth shut. And after year of swallowing that anger for she sake, Mike Wehner passed away of esophageal cancer in may 2007. There space some beautiful shots the Jean sitting alone top top a park bench as she recounts she memories that “her rock.” back this episode is full of clues in the mystery, ns love it because that these moments of reflection, as human being confront the full weight the the past bearing under on castle in every its beauty and tragedy.

Another such minute comes shortly after, once Gemma ultimately gets a call from Cathy’s sister Marilyn. They collection up an in-person meeting, but there’s one even an ext immediate impact. Gemma can’t believe how much Marilyn’s voice sounds like Cathy’s. After ~ hanging increase the phone, she just cries and cries.

After those emotionally journeys, the episode does leave us with a couple leads. Very first there’s Marilyn, who could be maybe to provide some much-needed information around the necklace. And also then there’s Edgar. Unlike dad Maskell, father Magnus, or Billy Schmidt, Edgar Davidson is really much lively — and just as scary as ever.

Who is Skippy? Billy Schmidt’s secret friend and maybe-lover is a huge unanswered question here, no least due to the fact that Sharon’s mom swears he when tried to run her off the road. Unfortunately, there is no a name or existing description, it’ll be difficult to uncover him, so ns wonder if this thread will certainly go anywhere.

What walk Edgar know? The biggest lead-in to the next episode, of course, is Edgar Davidson. The survivors that ‘70s Baltimore are either dead or so old your memory is untrustworthy. Is Edgar himself trustworthy? just how much will certainly he be ready to call — if he knows anything in ~ all?

Why space Sharon and also Debbie’s story so similar? Debbie says the similarity between her story and Sharon’s is proof of a conspiracy. Is that the answer, or did one of them copy the other? Or was one of them not associated to Cathy in ~ all?

Did the necklace have meaning other 보다 an august birthday? hope Marilyn have the right to answer this.

Fulfilling the promise of last episode’s cliffhanger, episode 6 starts off with an through the most most likely living suspect for Cathy Cesnik’s murder: Edgar Davidson.

Edgar is old now, v bushy gray hair and also a hard-to-understand voice. He’s tho “with it” an ext than Maskell remained in his later years, however. Edgar establish a picture of Cathy Cesnik, for instance (“that’s Cathy”), though he’s a small less receptive to a snapshot of Maskell, speak he never actually met him. Ultimately, Edgar usually denies culpability because that the crime. He confirms he said those incriminating things to his wife (and referred to as into a famous 1976 radio display to to speak he someone v Cathy’s rosary), claiming he said them come trick her right into thinking he to be involved. He says he was young and “stupid,” but offers little an ext than that. He says he wasn’t affiliated in the actual killing at all and also has no idea who was. Debbie warned us last episode that Edgar’s other of a trickster, who likes to play with world like a cat playing through a mouse, so who knows if he’s informing the truth or not. One of two people way, it’s all we’re gaining from him for now. No every murder suspect is going to traction a Robert Durst and just confess to whatever on tape.

The find for suspects currently turns to friendlier corners. In concentrating so lot on Maskell, The Keepers has not yet had time to look in ~ the human being who to be close to Cathy. And also boy, is there a lot come look at there.

First up is Gerry Koob. Mental him? He to be training to be a priest at the same time Cathy was training to be a nun, and also they fell in love. Gerry also proposed marital relationship at one point, just for Cathy to revolve it down and insist they stay on their preferred paths. The seemed like a great guy in the times we’ve checked out him up until now, however now we’re hearing about a potential other side. Investigative reporter Tom Nugent comes out together a large Koob skeptic and also swears a detective on the case once told him, “If Koob didn’t kill her, that knows who did.”

As it transforms out, Gerry’s alibi is kind of shaky. His story of the night Cathy disappeared has constantly been the same. Gerry states he went out that night with his friend, brother Pete McKeon. They gained dinner and also saw Easy Rider, climate headed ago to Baltimore as soon as they gained a contact from Cathy’s roommate, sister Russell Phillips. As Gerry says, “Pete to be my alibi, and also I was his.” Nugent has uncovered a hole in the story, though: Nugent, in his vibrant phrasing, recommends taking everything Gerry states with “a huge boulder that salt.”

As if prove his point, Gerry tells a story so vibrant it seems obviously fake. The says into the camera the while he to be being interrogated by the police end Cathy’s murder, one detective Cathy’s vagina ~ above the table in prior of him, sheathe in nrwandachamber.orgspaper. Both man Barnold of Baltimore City Police and Gary Childs of county refute the story. Barnold states he would never have enabled such strategies under his watch and that Koob’s story sounds an ext like “a dream,” when Childs simply says it sounds a tiny “out there.” however if Gerry is lying or exaggerating this story, as he obviously appears to be, what else can he be lying about?

In bespeak to find out, the team tries getting to out to Pete McKeon. However like Edgar, Pete is obtaining on in years, and also his memory is more than likely unreliable. Come guard versus that, the recites the very same story he’s been informing police for decades (movie, dinner, call, back to Baltimore), so we don’t acquire anything The slim amount the time that has actually passed in this investigation method that even promising threads frequently hit a dead finish or fade right into nothing, through the principals either dead or forgetful.

Take sister Russell, for example. Bud Roemer as soon as told Nugent the Russell had actually “the key to unlock this whole thing,” however unfortunately Cathy’s friend never ever told everyone what she – not even Patricia Gilner, that temporarily took end Cathy’s room with her. Another an enig gone come the grave.

Having grown up Catholic, I regularly laugh at jokes prefer John Mulaney’s humorous summary of the Irish-Catholic attitude toward life: “I’ll store all my emotions right here, and then one day, I’ll die.” It deserve to be an excellent for laughs, yet as we watch in this series, that mindset of Catholic self-repression is really real, really prevalent, and also has brought about lasting damages to people’s lives.

Importantly, the repression was also institutional. One former cop claims Maskell to be arrested at one allude — he could’ve only gained out of that one via security from both church and also state. In one of the most dramatic confrontations that the episode, film housing Ryan White presents former D.A. Sharon might with a perform of 50 abusive priests published by the Baltimore archdiocese in 2002. Only one name on the list was discovered guilty the sex crimes, and also he pleaded guilty. May has nothing to say come this, of course, just much more nonsense about how “the proof wasn’t there” — and there’s no method to double-check, since all the evidence related to Maskell has been destroyed. Among the huge takeaways native this show: just as the takes a town to progressive a child, it also takes a town to abuse a child and protect the abuser.

Luckily, in enhancement to every the investigative details in this episode, we also get a look at the world trying to conquer the damage of repression. Cathy’s sisters Marilyn, for example, preserved quiet about the instance for a long time for this reason as no to upset her parents, though she constantly carried Cathy’s memory with her. (“When Cathy died I said, ‘You will certainly not die as long as I’m alive. You will not die.’”) Now, Abbie and Gemma’s search has shed light top top some points for she (she didn’t also know about the Maskell link until recently) and connected her v the necklace Cathy intended for her. The eco-friendly birthstone, in fact, shows up to referral the August birthday of Marilyn’s husband, Bob.

Jean, too, has uncovered some healing over the food of this project. Abbie and also Gemma’s movement has linked her with other abuse survivors from Keogh, and also it’s assisted her discover solidarity and comfort in numbers.

The illustration ends by proving Jean right. Among her biggest disputes with police came from her insurance claim that Maskell confirmed her Cathy’s maggot-covered corpse, which cops always insisted was impossible due to the fact that it to be the winter, also cold because that maggots to breed outside. But when Gemma ultimately gets ahold of the autopsy report, courtesy the Marilyn, she finds proof the there were maggots in Cathy’s mouth and also throat.

Jean to be right. She was likely right about the other things, too.

Burning Questions

Is Gerry lying? whereby on earth did he obtain that vagina story?

What go Russell perform or know? did she betray Cathy to Maskell for part reason? Unfortunately, it doesn’t look favor we’ll ever get an answer to this question.

Is there a solution? We’ll find out next episode.

—Christian Holub(Click ahead for illustration 7)

EPISODE 7: “The Conclusion”

We start off the final episode of The Keepers with an introduction to another victim that Maskell’s abuse, a man named Charles Franz. Similar to Jean Wehner, Charles’ recollections the his abuse space horrifying in your complexity. In addition to physical and also sexual abuse, Maskell also introduced Charles come alcohol and drugs as a way to forget the pain. Yet perhaps this is the many horrifying information of all: Maskell was abusing Charles in 1967 — two years before Cathy’s death, prior to Maskell was moved from St. Clement Church come Archbishop Keough. Charles puts the bluntly: “If the Catholic Church had faced this properly in ’67, there would be no murder. We wouldn’t be here.”

Up until now, we’ve heard around some horrifying points in this show: rape, murder, betrayal, repression. This finale is devoted to unspooling the Catholic Church’s role in this events, their continuous complicity in repressing the victim of priest abuse, and also the cooperation and protection they receive from the government in law so.

First, though, some final notes top top the Cesnik case. Edgar Davidson continues to deny involvement, has no answer for why he remained in possession the the necklace Cathy bought for her sister’s engagement, and just normally doesn’t seem favor anybody’s gonna gain anything the end of him in ~ this point. There are still some leads, though. Barbara Schmidt notes that her brother-in-law Billy Schmidt supplied to smoke Salem cigarettes – walk the police find any kind of cigarettes in ~ the scene? Forensic proof has improved a lot since the ‘70s; perhaps they might use that to acquire some DNA? as soon as director Ryan White mentions this come Gary Childs, the Baltimore county detective confirms v a laugh the they did collection a tobacco from the scene. Back Childs decreases to talk about the police’s recurring investigation, he notes that whatever White has told that is an extremely interesting. He assures to look at everything and also has confidence the situation can still be cracked (FYI, the DNA they eventually pulled indigenous the scene does not complement Maskell’s).

The Malecki family, unfortunately, does not share his trust in their very own case. Joyce Malecki’s murder has flown under the radar somrwandachamber.orghat throughout this show, because its connection to Cathy’s fatality remains unclear. The Malecki family members is used to that; criminal authorities have been offering them the cold shoulder for years now. As among Joyce’s making it through brothers says, “If there’s nothing, someone need to tell us.” Instead, the FBI refuses to tell anyone anything. Abbie and also Gemma have actually now gone almost three years because their early stage FOIA request for Malecki evidence and have obtained nothing however perfunctory replies. The Maleckis, rightfully, feeling abandoned.

They aren’t the only ones. Because there’s a seven-year state of restrictions on sex crimes, survivors have avenues because that pursuing righteousness if the takes them longer than the to come forward about their experiences. One Maryland state assemblyman, C.T. Wilson, has been trying to introduce a bill that would give survivors more time to document suits, only to clock it dice in committee over and also over again there is no going to a vote. In hearings because that the bill, Wilson confesses that he himself is a survivor, having actually been abused by his adoptive father because that years. Various other survivors favor Teresa Lancaster (the onetime “Jane Roe”) come front to share your experiences. Castle talk around how gaining over child abuse take away a long time, and also survivors shouldn’t be punished.

If you thought the Catholic Church would certainly deploy lawyers especially to controversy why those survivors should be punished in that matter, you’ve most likely been paying attention to this show. One such lawyer, Kevin Murphy, was the same male who decades earlier grilled Teresa and Jean when they tried to sue the Church over their abuse. Murphy’s debates are as tough to watch, in their way, together Jean’s an initial descriptions of her abuse ago in episode 2.

Their disagreements ring hollow in the wake up of emotionally appeals from abuse survivors, however once again the Church gets its way. Wilson confesses to White (adding the this could an extremely well end his career) the committee chairs store the invoice from going come a vote since they and also the Church both know it would pass. It wake up again this time, though Wilson vows to shot again. Virwandachamber.orgers will most likely be happy to know that his third attempt at the invoice succeeded, and was signed right into law by Maryland Gov. Larry Hogan in April.

The U.S. Constitution mandates the separation that church and state, however that border is a little much more porous in places like Baltimore, whereby the Church has actually long held a many of cultural and political influence. Wilson argues that this saga demonstrates exactly why together separation is required — once the Church victimizes human being in this way, it’s the government’s duty come intercede and carry out justice because that people.

The final act the this illustration lays the end the Church’s very own failure to carry out such justice. As soon as Jean sued the Church in the ‘90s, their argument was the she short corroboration for her claims, the there necessary to be someone rather saying the Maskell abused students. As it transforms out, Charles Franz is life proof of such corroboration. He insurance claims that once his mommy learned exactly how Maskell was abusing him, she complained directly to the Archdiocese, i m sorry promptly moved Maskell indigenous Charles’ institution to Archbishop Keough. In addition to leading to untold rapes and also (most likely) the murder of Cathy Cesnik, this relocate is likrwandachamber.orgise proof that the Church around Maskell as early as 1967. The Church lied to Jean, a lie the Archdiocese doubled down on in their composed responses to questions from White as soon as they again claimed that Jean to be the an initial person to come forward through allegations versus Maskell. Both Jean and Charles space angry, but not entirely surprised.

See more: Highspeed Pc Top Deck Tech Station, Tech Stations

So what now? once both church and state failure to provide justice for your most fragile citizens, the task must then fall to the human being themselves. This display started v Tom Nugent wondering why Abbie and Gemma didn’t walk the classic investigative reporter path for your story. Yet their grassroots movement has done therefore much much more than any of these other institutions. Abbie and Gemma uncovered interesting details in the case, but much more importantly, they obtained various injured human being in call with every other. Together they say here, no matter exactly how it happened, Cathy’s murderer feels linked to the systemic abuse the went on at Archbishop Keough and around the country. So though she murder continues to be unsolved, the find for truth has helped some survivors find some measure up of comfort, peace, and, many importantly, connection. As Keough shuts down for good, Jean and her friends erect a memorial plaque come Cathy Cesnik — to the woman who stuck up because that them as soon as she to be alive, and who carried them together again in death.