Have a discuss this story? write to the editors. Encompass your full name, city and state. Selected comments will be edited for publication in print or online.

You are watching: Jesus was born to die

While some lament that Christmas has end up being increasingly secularized and also materialistic, others have actually posted blogs and also Facebook statuses reminding us of the real meaning the Christmas.

Recently, Benjamin L. Corey released a very thought-provoking, well-articulated and convincing post titled “No, Jesus wasn’t Born to die (The part of the Christmas Story us Mess Up).” Corey argues that Christ’s birth to be not mainly meant to end in death, however rather took location in stimulate to show us how to live. Corey’s premise is intriguing and also helpful in allowing an Anabaptist Christian space to wrestle with several of the an essential points of our theology. For plenty of of united state who case Anabaptism together our confidence tradition, we recognize the prominence of social justice and also peacemaking in a selection of settings. We live out our confidence in an active and engaging way, fairly than as passive observers. Us dismantle the idea of God merely appeasing his wrath and replace it through a theology of love and also service. Corey definitely has earned mine respect in this regard. However, ns disagree v the main theme the his post. Ns would favor to argue the Yes, Jesus to be born come die, yet that’s no the only reason he came.

Over the past several years, I have actually noticed a transition in church theology by which words choose “sin” and also “judgment” are considered archaic and also even abusive. Some Christians wonder exactly how God might possibly have killed his own Son (isn’t that divine child abuse?). Others imply that Jesus willingly went through his suffering and consequent fatality in order to espouse a theology of society justice. Many case that Jesus’ death and also resurrection to be symbolic of the breaking down of opening systems and that Christ’s sacrifice to be nothing much more than a moral example to the remainder of us.

I have actually studied many of the atonement theory in-depth, and also I have concerned see the merits and shortfalls in almost every one of them. I believe there space definite piece each one contributes to the puzzle and that over there are reasons to agree with one over the other. Return I prospered up in a church that believed solely in penal substitution (meaning Christ needed to die in bespeak to transfer our own punishment ~ above himself), I additionally agree heartily v the moral example theory. In plenty of ways, Christ did come to present us the right means of living. He did many radical points in his life that caused people to wonder. That pushed ago on concerns that to be restrictive He consistently stood up for those that were no able to insurance claim their very own voice. Furthermore, Christ taught countless moral and also ethical lessons. He healed people with debilitating conditions in order to offer them earlier their life and social status. He at some point showed v his fatality the elevation of what it way to a non-resister in the confront of oppression and also extreme violence.

All these things room very good and important for united state to take note of. However, the main point of who Jesus is was not a moral teacher. He to be (and is) the child of God. Our churches have actually a tendency to downplay the seriousness of ours own human depravity. Rather of focussing on individual ills and also wrong-doings, we have tendency to to water our efforts into see the whole creation and systemic structure as lopsided. Thus, we promote economic and also environmental stability, we protest poverty and violations of person rights, and we practice civil disobedience when need be.

Yet to relegate Christ to merely the standing of “the best moral teacher who ever lived” is to strip him completely of his rightful condition as kid of God and savior the the world. The very word “savior” suggests that over there is miscellaneous we have to be saved from. Not just do we must be saved from the impact of violence and the ravages of war, yet we primarily need to be saved from the mess we have created for ourself that stems indigenous our very own wrongful check out of ourselves, the in its entirety creation, and God. This is ideal described as sin.


In his groundbreaking book, If You will Ask, Oswald Chambers poses the complying with question: “Are we merely devotees the a social cause or are we disciples of Christ?” ns think God calls all Christians to it is in both. However, at the core of our worship and our theology lies the acknowledgement that Christ is qualified of doing something much greater than any type of other moral teacher was ever able come accomplish. He died in stimulate to set us cost-free and to allow us come share an eternity in heaven v him.

When us look in ~ the Bible, we watch a magnificent drama starting in the very first chapter that Genesis and then swiftly relocating toward Revelation (from the origins of our humankind to the culmination that the new humanity). Oh my gosh original architecture for this human being was perfection. Yet, due to the fact that of free will, humanity made decision to go the wrong way. We determined our own direction in ours pride, fairly than oh my gosh direction in our humility. This resulted in sin beginning this world within the very first generation. And also the scriptures tells united state that through sin came death, destruction, and also disease.

Yet, over there was great news — really great news. God is holy and thus not able come look top top imperfections (thus the reason for every the sacrifices in the Old Testament), yet he is likewise merciful, expanding his mercy come generations top top generations that those that will only call out come him to obtain them into himself. As soon as sin enters the world, God gives a solution. The equipment doesn’t take place for thousands of years; however, God promises it will ultimately take place. Whereas human beings chose death over life, God the Father chose life end death. God proclaims the one will certainly come who will have actually the strength to like the an extremely one (Satan) responsible for this mishap. The remainder of the holy bible follows the premise of Christ eventually ending up being the victor over death.

Repeatedly we review prophetic utterances that point to Christ’s appearance. An especially in Isaiah 53, we check out that we will certainly be cure by Christ’s sacrifice. The bible shows us that Christ is may be to perform what we as people are can not to do. We needed someone pure and perfect come erase our own impurity and also imperfection.

Eventually we wind up in the brand-new Testament, where the story of Jesus yes, really takes off. Mary submits come God’s will certainly for her and gives bear to Christ, who the angels then prayer from the highest heights and also urge shepherds and also other villagers to see. The fact that Christ came into this human being through a virgin is significant. It reflects that his enntrance gate was not tainted through what others might perceive as “mere physical means.” Rather, he was collection apart by God right from the start and appointed to a specific task.

Corey interestingly poses the question: “If it to be all around dying, why can not the infant in the manger just have actually died? the would have done the trick.” ns submit that this concern really lacks the theological depth of every Jesus involved do and all the was. Jesus’ atoning fatality resulted indigenous his ability to to speak yes to it. His willingness to submit to the Father at some point showed his love. Because that God, it no merely around the sacrifice, but about the an approach and reason behind the sacrifice. God is no a merciless baby-slayer, but he IS a patience sin-slayer. Isaiah points come this when he writes that “he took our punishments ~ above us, by his wounds we room healed” (Isaiah 53:5).

Corey additionally challenges the factor for the sacrifice. He says that God abhorred person sacrifices; thus, why would he demand this really thing from his very own beloved Son? Corey’s first statement is correct — God did clearly state the didn’t desire his children to action like bordering peoples who willingly eliminated their children off in order to appease a fake god. However, because Jesus Christ was not merely a human, however God himself, this renders the entirety premise much an ext difficult. I don’t think the something ours finite human being minds have the right to grasp. How might God it is in dead and also still life at the same time? and it is because of this confusing passage that I recognize a few believers that really struggle with the principle of the Trinity. While i cannot offer a clear answer on this, all I have the right to say is the it totally shows the depth of the Father’s love because that us. He can have completely held united state under once we messed up, however instead he chose to do the most damaging thing in order to present us true life. If this isn’t the height of love, mercy and also forgiveness, ns don’t understand what is. And also this is where I appreciate what Corey claimed — because at the main point of what this blog post is around is how come live, but also why Christ died.

So us celebrate Christ’s birth, and also it is essential to invest time relishing his arrival. We then invest the year going through the rest of his life. We have to not negate his miracles, his teachings, his compassion and his wisdom. We shouldn’t sirloin to great Friday, however should take it time to pause and reflect top top his life. To just say Christ involved die is no enough, but to merely say Christ came just in order to display us exactly how to live is additionally to miss the suggest entirely. It’s type of prefer attending a funeral. When a eulogy is given, us don’t dwell top top the truth the person is dead — we recount his or her life. And that’s what we carry out with Christ. However we additionally don’t i disbanded his death lightly.

When we live in the here and now, it deserve to be straightforward to forget that there is a heaven. C.S. Lewis referred to us together being small children contents to play through mudcakes all the if forgetting that there is a better vacation around to take place. We cannot spend our lives too concentrated on death, though, or else we’d never do anything because that the common great of humanity. Top top the various other hand, we also cannot forget that death will take on all of us, or we will only focus on the earthly and forget the eternal.

I evaluate Corey’s cutting-edge ideas and also his all at once concern with ethical welfare. I relate to his questions worrying some that the an ext troubling i of Scripture and also his rings with how we, as Anabaptist pacifists, address them. I support Corey’s conclusion the Jesus’ life has countless moral and also ethical lessons to teach us, which us should more readily become aware of fairly than simply reaching because that a straightforward “Sunday school answer.” However, I basically disagree with his premise. Jesus did no just come come die, yet his atoning sacrificial death was possibly the most important part of why he came. Jesus to be born in order to die, and also by that fatality to ultimately display us exactly how to live.

See more: How To Unlock Second Coil Of Bahamut Raids? How Do You Unlock The Coil Of Bahamut Savage

Deborah-Ruth Ferber is a field associate through the Anabaptist Disabilities Network currently residing in Ontario. This post very first appeared at Zwiebach and also Peace, her an individual blog.