Bird box vs. A Quiet Place: just how The Monster movie Are various Bird crate seems similar to A Quiet Place however the two sensory-deprived 2018 horror films have many vital differences - and also important things in common.

You are watching: Bird box vs a quiet place



Bird Box has been drawing comparisons come A Quiet Place, but despite some surface similarities, the 2 horror movies are actually quite different. Since it was released in December, manager Susanne Bier"s Bird Box has become a hit because that Netflix and also a famous sensation, with clever and also funny memes spreading roughly the Internet and some fans acquisition on the "Bird box Challenge" (which is not urged by Netflix).

Directed, co-written, and starring man Krasinski, A Quiet Place additionally became a hit once it premiered in April 2018. Set in a post-apocalyptic world, the Abbott family members headed by Lee (Krasinski) and his mam Evelyn (Emily Blunt) strive to endure in silence after the civilization has been got into by extraterrestrial creatures that savagely kill anything that makes a sound. Meanwhile, Bird Box stars Sandra Bullock as Malorie, a woman who tries to guide two five-year-old youngsters to safety in a post-apocalyptic human being where they must remain blindfolded or else they can loss victim to mysterious reality that will drive them come commit suicide.


Related: Bird Box"s ending & monsters Explained

Both films utilize the finish of the people to discover themes that survival and humanity, and also both A Quiet Place and also Bird Box pressure the audience come imagine themselves in these complicated scenarios, in order to asking hard questions about what friend would perform in the characters" places. But by spring deeper and listening a bit more closely, we can discover how deftly both films challenge the human problem in your own distinct ways:

This Page: vision Vs. Sound, survival Vs. Living

Sight Vs. Sound


Sandra Bullock with kids in Bird Box
Both A Quiet Place and also Bird Box use deprivation of one of our five senses as the backbone the their fear scenario - although in A Quiet Place, it"s the monsters who are blind. In Krasinski"s film, humanity was wiped out by an intrusion of sightless monsters the massacre anything the creates a sound. This forces the Abbott family members to find a means to endure without making any kind of kind of noise; a daunting an obstacle considering Lee and Evelyn room parents come young children. Indeed, A Quiet Place grippingly establishes the stakes early on by illustrating how the Abbotts lose their youngest son, Beau, that is eliminated by a creature as soon as playing with a toy spaceship that provides noise. The film likewise powerfully makes use of silence and trying to remain quiet at all times to change the ladder tension, making the occasional bursts of sound or the fleeting moment of conversation all the an ext effective.


Indeed, the titular bird box - bird Malorie keeps in a box due to the fact that their chirping action as very early warning mechanism - would certainly spell doom in A Quiet Place. However, as difficult as it might be to stay quiet at all times, Bird Box arguably one-ups A Quiet Place"s gimmick by remove the ability to see. Bird Box compellingly conveys the frantic Malorie make the efforts to move her two children down a flow to a feasible sanctuary while every one of them remain blindfolded. Their case only intensifies as castle are attacked by an insane man, have to survive the river"s rapids, and also are also taunted to eliminate their blindfolds by Bird Box"s unknown monsters" psychological attacks. Few of Bird Box"s action sequences may stretch credibility, but Bullock gives someone come genuinely source for, which alleviates shock that Malorie is maybe to execute the points she walk while remaining blindfolded (the film additionally helps with a five-year time jump the infers Malorie has trained herself to survive without sight throughout that time).


Related: Bird Box cast Guide: whereby You recognize The gibbs From

Both films consider the difficulties of shedding one the our 5 senses, i m sorry is do immeasurably worse by the presence of malevolent monsters out to death the characters, and both films additionally have rules that are a little inconsistent and illogical. However, it"s an ext important that Bird Box and A Quiet Place both contain the core belief that it"s an essential never to offer up, not autumn to despair, and also to save trying come survive since human life is worth fighting for no issue what, i m sorry is a vital to why audience have taken on both fear films.


John Krasinski and Emily blunt in A Quiet Place
Another significant difference is just how each film addresses how to live throughout the apocalypse. In Bird Box, Malorie, a woman that is already reluctantly pregnant when the human being ends, has to learn the life is much more than around mere survival. The film alternates in between the "present" that Malorie"s plight, to gain her children to safety and security with the occasions of 5 years prior once a supernatural afflict suddenly assaulted humanity and drove practically everyone to commit suicide. Malorie, who currently suffered a challenging childhood with an abusive father, experiences horrific tragedy choose the brutal suicide of she sister Jessica (Sarah Paulson) and also the organized deaths that the people she to be living in a safe home with. Even before her lover, Tom (Trevante Rhodes), sacrificed self to save her and the kids from the people worshipping the unseen monsters, Malorie to be a pessimist (or realist) who refused to surname the youngsters other 보다 "Boy" and "Girl," due to the fact that she didn"t desire to administer them with false hope of a life they would certainly never be able to have. When they lastly reached your sanctuary - a fortified school because that the blind - Malorie learned to accept a sliver of expect at the end of Bird Box that she and also her youngsters can live a better kind that life.

See more: Champs Black Friday 2016 - Black Friday Is Here At Champs Sports


Related: A Quiet Place"s monsters & finishing Explained

Meanwhile, the Abbotts in A Quiet Place admirably refused to surrender their household to the apocalypse - and that an option to hit to keep their family costs them dearly. After they lost Beau, the family is presented a year later on having worked out on a farm and also carving the end a life because that themselves. Also with their countless rules and precautions to avoid making sounds, the Abbotts had household dinners and attempted a type of domestic normalcy. Indeed, the central challenge that the film was the reality that Evelyn was pregnant and the Abbotts to be going to attempt to progressive a baby in this world. Despite their soundproof rooms and also their preparations, the aliens invaded the Abbotts" farm, forcing Lee to do the ultimate sacrifice to conserve his family (not unequal Tom in Bird Box), leaving Evelyn alone through her 3 children. Although your deaf daughter Regan (Millicent Simmonds) uncovered the monsters have actually a vulnerability they can exploit, A Quiet Place ends v a sense of doom because that the family members regardless together they"ve shed Lee and also they it seems to be ~ ill-equipped to continue to make it through - opposing of Bird Box"s more hopeful conclusion.